Thomas Lord
Housing Advisory Commission log
19 February 2018
An item to correct election irregularities that occured at the February HAC meeting.
To: Housing Advisory Commission
From: Commissioner Thomas Lord
Subject: Motion to correct officer elections
Date: 1 March 2018
At the February meeting, during the election of officers
The floor was not opened for nominations for Chair.
In lieu of nominations, a motion to appoint Igor Tregub chair was quickly made and seconded.
Without debate, a roll call vote on that motion commenced 16 seconds after the elections were taken up.
The election of Vice Chair followed a somewhat more regular order, but still without discussion or debate.
This Commission operates, loosely, under Roberts Rules of Order. Our elections, minimally, require a nomination period, discussion, a vote to close nominations, and an election.
The advantage to the Commission of following those by-laws is that the Commission is assured an opprtunity to discuss the election before a vote is taken. In this case, the Commission was deprived of that opportunity.
Votes not in accordance to the by-laws, say Roberts Rules, are technically null and void, though such strict interpretation may be hard to make stick, here.
That this Commission hold a brief discussion about our hopes and concerns for the management of the Commission this coming year, and then either take no action or vote to affirm the elections.